Neapolitan Pizza & Pasta · 76 Pearl Street, Buffalo
Old City Pizza
Brick-oven Neapolitan pizza, house-made pasta and bread. Pure wheat flour, D.O.P. San Marzano tomatoes and Italian extra virgin olive oil. A family recipe that started in Calabria, came to Niagara Falls in 1899, and finally made its way to Buffalo.
Gallery
Our Story
Before Old City Pizza, there was something else. A family legacy that started generations ago in Niagara Falls and quietly made its way back to Buffalo. This is not just a new spot in the city. It is a return to something real.
Buffalo Rising
Featuring brick-oven, Neapolitan-style pizza and homemade pasta and breads crafted with premium flour imported directly from Italy. Pearl Street and RiverWorks CEO Bill Casale has long family ties to the Western New York pizza scene. His family migrated to America in 1899 from Calabria, Italy, and is well known in Niagara Falls with historic venues such as Casale’s, which operated for almost 75 years.
Old City Pizza is taking things to a premium level with all clean ingredients and authentic Neapolitan style, featuring pure wheat flour, D.O.P. San Marzano tomatoes and Italian extra virgin olive oil.
Pure wheat flour. D.O.P. San Marzano tomatoes. Italian extra virgin olive oil.
Also Serving
SpoT Coffee
Coffee & Tea
Regular / Large
Brewed Coffee
$3.25 / $3.75
Iced Coffee
$4.25 / $4.75
Hot Tea
$3.95
Iced Tea
$4.25 / $4.75
Chai Latte
$5.50 / $5.95
Matcha Latte
$5.75 / $6.25
Hot Chocolate
$4.50 / $4.95
Espresso
Espresso
$3.50
Cortado
$4.50
Latte
$5.25 / $5.75
Cappuccino
$5.25 / $5.75
Caramel Macchiato
$5.75 / $6.25
Mocha
$5.50 / $5.95
Americano
$4.25 / $4.50
Red Eye
$5.50 / $5.95
Shakes & Smoothies
Cinco Shake
$6.25 / $6.75
Espresso, white chocolate, caramel and vanilla, topped with whipped cream.
Mocha Shake
$6.25 / $6.75
Espresso, chocolate sauce, topped with whipped cream.
Java Shake
$6.25 / $6.75
Espresso, vanilla syrup, topped with whipped cream.
Protein Power Shake
$7.95
Whey or plant based protein powder, fruit puree, banana.
Fruit Smoothie
$6.50
Flavors: strawberry, mango, peach, strawberry banana.
Add Ons
Flavor Shot
$0.85
Additional Flavored Sauces
$1.00
Homemade Whipped Cream
$1.00
Cold Foam
$1.00
Soy, Almond or Oat Milk
No charge
Great food. Good people.
Old City style.
Happy Hour & Cocktail Parties
The VIP cellar bar
From small office gatherings to birthday parties, or any celebration, we have the right option for you. Perfect for parties of 15 to 30 people, our happy hour cocktail style parties let your guests enjoy a casual meeting place with minimal effort, and premium food and spirits.
All items are cooked in our brick oven, and pizzas are Neapolitan style, made with all clean ingredients from Italy. Perfect for pre and post wedding parties, or special VIP occasions.
Pizza Party Package
10 to 15 people$170
- 1 Margherita pizza
- 1 pepperoni pizza
- 1 four cheese pizza
- Choice of 2 specialty pizzas
- Choice of 1 large salad
- Warm focaccia bread
Pasta Party Package
10 to 15 people$240
- Choice of pasta and sauce
- Choice of 10 chicken cutlets or 20 meatballs
- Choice of 1 large salad
- Warm focaccia bread
Grandma’s Dinner Table
20 to 30 people$600
- 2 Margherita pizzas
- 2 pepperoni pizzas
- 2 four cheese pizzas
- Choice of 4 specialty pizzas
- Choice of 2 large salads
- Choice of pasta and sauce
- 10 chicken cutlets
- 20 meatballs
- Warm focaccia bread
Deposit required. 48 hour notice. Tax and gratuity are additional.
All spaces are filled on a first come, first served basis. For space availability please fill out the form at the bottom of this page.
Testimonials
From the first bite I knew I would be back. Old City Pizza serves up incredible food with fresh, clean ingredients you can feel good about, all wrapped in friendly service that keeps you coming back. I highly recommend!
Amanda E · Hamburg, NY
There is not a single item on the menu that I would not recommend. The staff is super friendly and very interactive! The bread is made in house. 10 out of 10!
Mike K
Hours & Location
Find us on Pearl Street
Old City Pizza
SpoT Coffee
Book the space